Austin Citizens for Personal Rapid Transit
 
.
Home
Austin's Transport Challenge
What is PRT?
PRT For Austin
PRT Benefits
PRT FAQs
How to Help
Skeptic's Corner
 Performance and Service
 Safety and Security
 Design and Costs
Discussion Archives
Links
About ACPRT
Mailing List
Site Map
. . .
 

Personal Rapid Transit One-Way Guideway Design

Concern:  

Why the one-way guideways? Two-way guideways are better and keep the travel time identical for both legs of a trip.

Reply:   While dual guideways can be used in PRT systems if needed, it is more productive to split the dual guideway into two one-way guideways located some distance apart. Large vehicle systems often use the double-tracked configuration, allowing one station to serve passengers going in either direction. But the cost components that help drive that decision are not the same in the PRT system.
  • PRT stations are far smaller than rail transit stations. Their small footprint means lower costs for each station, and less need to reduce station numbers.

  • The fully elevated nature of the PRT station would allow little of the structure to be shared by both directions. Many dual direction stations would have to have stairways, elevators, and ticketing equipment on both sides of the station since customers cannot walk across the guideways and mid-platform stations will often be impractical.

  • The small size of PRT guideways greatly reduces right of way costs, thus reducing the justification of using the two-way design.

  • The one-way design allows over twice as much service area to be served by the system for much less than twice the costs. This occurs because the additional right of way costs are relativly small. Most of the costs are from guideways and stations that are already required for the dual-direction system design.

  • The added ridership from the additional stations and service area is far greater than the number of people who won't use the system due to the small difference in travel times for the two legs of a commute.

While some cost savings could be obtained by dual-direction systems, it would come at the sacrifice of the ridership and revenue generated along the second guideway. This revenue is expected to be more than the costs of the additional right of way.

PRT Skeptic's Pages

Here we attempt to address issues brought to us by PRT skeptics in a question and answer format. If you have a concern that you think should be addressed, send us an email at Info@ACPRT.org or fill out the Skeptic's Question form and we will do our best to answer it.

Be sure to check back every once in a while as we will be adding items from time to time.

.
Austin Citizens for Personal Rapid Transit
P.O. Box 161972, Austin, TX 78716-1972
Questions, Comments, Suggestions? Info@ACPRT.org
Site development and hosting by Computer Consulting Company